e.l.f. cleans as well as Clinique. Clinique's extra cost buys a fragrance-free formula.
In the Clinique Take the Day Off vs e.l.f. balm question, the cleaning is a tie. Both use light esters to dissolve makeup and sunscreen and an emulsifier to rinse it off. e.l.f. costs roughly half as much per ounce.
The difference is fragrance. Clinique has none, has only nine ingredients, and is ophthalmologist-tested. e.l.f. contains fragrance, plus geraniol and linalool, along with ceramides and hyaluronic acid that make it feel a little softer after rinsing.
If your skin or eyes react to fragrance, Clinique is worth paying for. If not, buy e.l.f. The Charcoal Clinique is the original in a different color and doesn’t clean any better.
Both balms melt makeup and sunscreen and rinse clean. The question is whether a fragrance-free formula is worth about twice the cost per ounce to you.
Three balms, three cases
What the extra money buys
Both balms clean the same way. Light esters dissolve makeup and sunscreen, a wax keeps the balm solid, and a PEG emulsifier turns it milky so it rinses off. Clinique uses sorbeth-30 tetraoleate and PEG-5 glyceryl triisostearate. e.l.f. uses PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate and PEG-10 isostearate. Either setup rinses clean when you add water gradually.
The real difference is what else is in the jar. Clinique is fragrance-free and has nine ingredients. e.l.f. contains fragrance, plus three ceramides, cholesterol, hyaluronic acid and two peptides. The extras make e.l.f. feel a bit softer after rinsing. The fragrance makes it the riskier pick for sensitive skin and eyes.
If you wear water-resistant sunscreen daily, either balm handles it. See how well gentle cleansers remove sunscreen for when you need a second step.
Both come in screw-top jars, so you'll be dipping fingers or a spatula in either way.
Side by side, the differences come down to fragrance, size and extras.
| VS | ||
|---|---|---|
About twice e.l.f. | Cost per ounce |
About half Clinique |
1, 3.8 or 6.7 oz | Jar sizes |
2 oz |
None | Fragrance |
Added fragrance, geraniol, linalool |
Sorbeth-30 tetraoleate, PEG-5 glyceryl triisostearate | Emulsifiers |
PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate, PEG-10 isostearate |
None (9 ingredients) | Extras |
3 ceramides, hyaluronic acid, peptides |
| View | View |
Here's what each jar actually contains, starting with Clinique.
Clinique Take the Day Off: nine ingredients, no fragrance
Fragrance-free, nine ingredients, safe around eyes.
Take the Day Off has one of the shortest lists in the category. Ethylhexyl palmitate, safflower oil and caprylic/capric triglyceride dissolve makeup and sunscreen. Sorbeth-30 tetraoleate and PEG-5 glyceryl triisostearate turn it milky with water so it rinses clean. Polyethylene keeps it solid. The rest is water, vitamin E and a preservative.
It’s fragrance-free, dermatologist- and ophthalmologist-tested, and labeled safe for sensitive eyes. That’s the real difference from e.l.f. It doesn’t clean better; it just leaves out the things most likely to sting. It comes in 1 oz, 3.8 oz and 6.7 oz jars.
- Fragrance-free
- Ophthalmologist-tested and labeled safe for sensitive eyes
- Only nine ingredients
- Non-comedogenic and non-acnegenic
- Costs about twice as much per ounce as e.l.f.
- No extras like ceramides
- Doesn’t clean any better than e.l.f.
e.l.f. is built to do the same job for less, and it does.
e.l.f. Holy Hydration: same job, about half the cost
Same cleaning power, about half the cost per ounce.
e.l.f. is built like Clinique. Cetyl ethylhexanoate and caprylic/capric triglyceride dissolve makeup and sunscreen, polyethylene keeps it solid, and PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate plus PEG-10 isostearate let it rinse clean. It melts on contact and turns milky with water.
It goes further on extras: ceramides NP, AP and EOP, cholesterol, hydrolyzed hyaluronic acid and two peptides. In a rinse-off, those mainly keep skin from feeling tight. The trade-off is fragrance. It contains added fragrance plus geraniol and linalool, which can sting sensitive skin and eyes. If cleansers often sting you, see why cleansers sting. The jar holds 2 oz.
- Same cleaning approach: light esters plus PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate
- About half the cost per ounce of Clinique’s 3.8 oz jar
- Three ceramides and hyaluronic acid soften the finish
- Contains fragrance, geraniol and linalool
- Small 2 oz jar
- Peptides do little in a rinse-off
Clinique also makes a Charcoal version. It's the same cleanser in a different color.
Clinique Charcoal: the same balm in black
The original formula, tinted black with charcoal.
The Charcoal balm uses the same base as the original: ethylhexyl palmitate, safflower oil and caprylic/capric triglyceride, with sorbeth-30 tetraoleate and PEG-5 glyceryl triisostearate to rinse. The differences are synthetic wax in place of polyethylene and charcoal powder for color. It’s still fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested.
Clinique aims it at dry-combination to oily skin. Charcoal doesn’t clean deeper in a rinse-off product, so buy it only if you prefer it.
- Same emulsifiers as the original: sorbeth-30 tetraoleate and PEG-5 glyceryl triisostearate
- Fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested
- Dark color shows where you missed a spot
- Charcoal adds nothing to cleansing
- Black balm looks messy around the eyes
- Costs much more per ounce than e.l.f.
The black balm makes leftover product easy to spot, but it can look messy around your eyes. If you use a balm as your eye-makeup remover, the clear original is easier to work with.
Charcoal won’t treat acne in a product you rinse off in a minute.
So the choice comes down to one question: does fragrance bother your skin or eyes?
Which cleansing balm is worth it?
Short version: the cheaper balm cleans just as well. Clinique's extra cost buys a fragrance-free formula tested around the eyes. If you need that, it's worth it. If you don't, it isn't.
Which one to buy
Choose e.l.f. Holy Hydration if fragrance doesn’t bother you. In the Clinique Take the Day Off vs e.l.f. balm matchup, the two clean equally well: light esters dissolve makeup, emulsifiers rinse it off. e.l.f. costs roughly half as much per ounce and adds ceramides for a softer finish.
Choose Clinique if you have sensitive skin or sensitive eyes. It’s fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested and has just nine ingredients. That’s what the extra money buys. Skip the Charcoal version unless you prefer it; it cleans the same as the original. For help choosing what follows the balm, see our gentle cleanser guide.
