Same size, same humectants. One has niacinamide and the other doesn't.
Vanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer vs CeraVe PM looks like a toss-up: both are 3 fl oz, fragrance-free, non-comedogenic lotions with glycerin, hyaluronic acid and ceramides. The difference that matters is niacinamide. CeraVe PM lists it fourth, a real dose. Vanicream has none.
Choose CeraVe PM for oily, combination or breakout-prone skin, or if you want help with redness and uneven tone. It’s light, oil-free and comes in a pump. Choose Vanicream for sensitive or reactive skin, or if niacinamide has made you flush. Squalane makes it a touch richer, and it skips silicones, botanicals and essential oils. Despite the name, both work morning or night.
- Niacinamide: CeraVe PM yes, Vanicream no.
- Oily or combination skin: CeraVe PM. Sensitive or normal-to-dry skin: Vanicream.
Pick by skin type, not by the PM on the label
Vanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer: plain, soft and niacinamide-free
Niacinamide-free squalane lotion for sensitive skin.
Vanicream’s moisturizer has 19 ingredients. Squalane is second, right after water, followed by glycerin and pentylene glycol. Squalane is a light emollient that leaves skin soft without feeling oily, so this lotion feels a little richer than CeraVe PM.
Hyaluronic acid comes next, then five ceramides (EOP, NG, NP, AS and AP), carnosine and phytosterols. There’s no niacinamide, no silicone, and no fragrance, botanical extracts, essential oils, dyes, parabens or lanolin. It’s non-comedogenic and comes in a 3 fl oz tube.
It fits well into a comparison of fragrance-free facial moisturizers if you want more options.
- No niacinamide or silicones
- Five ceramides plus phytosterols
- Squalane softens without greasiness
- No fragrance, botanicals, essential oils, dyes or parabens
- Non-comedogenic
- Slightly dewy finish on oily skin
- Not rich enough alone for very dry skin in winter
- Tube is less hygienic than a pump
Quick take A plain, comfortable moisturizer with very little to react to. The easy first try for sensitive skin.
Buy Vanicream if your skin is reactive, if niacinamide has bothered you, or if your skin runs normal to dry. Squalane, glycerin, hyaluronic acid and five ceramides make a comfortable daily moisturizer with almost nothing likely to irritate. Oily skin will do better with CeraVe PM.
CeraVe PM: a light lotion with real niacinamide
Light, oil-free lotion with niacinamide.
CeraVe PM’s first four ingredients are water, glycerin, caprylic/capric triglyceride and niacinamide. That puts niacinamide at a level that can actually help with oiliness, redness, the look of pores and uneven tone over a few weeks.
Below that are ceramides NP, AP and EOP, cholesterol, phytosphingosine, sodium hyaluronate and a little dimethicone for slip. CeraVe’s MVE delivery is meant to release these slowly through the day. The result is a light, quick-absorbing lotion that’s oil-free, non-comedogenic and free of added fragrance, in a 3 fl oz pump.
Despite the name, it works just as well in the morning under sunscreen.
- Niacinamide fourth on the list
- Ceramides NP, AP and EOP with cholesterol
- Glycerin and hyaluronic acid
- Light, oil-free and non-comedogenic
- Hygienic pump bottle
- Niacinamide can flush very reactive skin
- Longer list than Vanicream
- Not rich enough alone for very dry skin
Quick take A light moisturizer with a real dose of niacinamide. Great for oily and combination skin; the wrong pick if niacinamide bothers you.
Buy CeraVe PM if your skin runs oily, combination or breakout-prone, or if you want niacinamide’s help with redness and uneven tone without adding a serum. It’s light, oil-free and works morning or night. Skip it if niacinamide has made you flush before.
Two tubes of the same Vanicream moisturizer
- Same formula as the single tube
- Fewer reorders
- Often lower cost per tube
- Bigger upfront spend
- A poor match leaves you with two tubes
If Vanicream is already your moisturizer, the two-pack saves a reorder and is worth it when it costs less per tube than two singles. If you haven’t tried it yet, buy one tube first.
How we compared them
We judged these two moisturizers on the ingredients that change how they feel and who they suit.
Niacinamide, ceramides, cholesterol, squalane and hyaluronic acid, and where each sits on the list.
Squalane against a light ester and dimethicone base, and how each layers under sunscreen and makeup.
Tube against pump, size, and whether the two-pack is the same formula.
Both are 3 fl oz, fragrance-free and non-comedogenic, so those didn’t separate them.
CeraVe PM’s extra ingredients do real work: niacinamide for oil and redness, dimethicone for slip. But each one is also something your skin could react to. Buy the formula whose extras you actually want.
| VS | ||
|---|---|---|
Glycerin, hyaluronic acid | Humectants |
Glycerin, hyaluronic acid |
EOP, NG, NP, AS, AP | Ceramides |
NP, AP, EOP |
Squalane, phytosterols | Other lipids |
Cholesterol, phytosphingosine |
None | Niacinamide |
Yes, 4th ingredient |
None | Silicone |
Dimethicone |
Soft, slightly dewy | Finish |
Light, silky |
3 fl oz tube | Packaging |
3 fl oz pump |
| View | View |
Both pair humectants with ceramides. Vanicream adds squalane and phytosterols for a softer, slightly richer feel. CeraVe PM adds cholesterol, dimethicone and a meaningful dose of niacinamide.
If you want niacinamide’s help with oil, redness and tone, buy CeraVe PM. If niacinamide has bothered you, or you just want the plainest list, buy Vanicream.
Five ceramides vs. three
Ceramides are the main lipids in the skin's outer layer, the part that keeps water in and irritants out. Vanicream lists five types and CeraVe PM lists three, but more types doesn't mean more ceramide overall.
Your barrier works best when ceramides come with cholesterol and fatty acids. Here's how each formula covers that:
- Vanicream: ceramides EOP, NG, NP, AS and AP, plus phytosterols (plant cousins of cholesterol) and squalane.
- CeraVe PM: ceramides NP, AP and EOP, plus cholesterol and phytosphingosine.
- Both: the ceramides sit mid-list, so they're there in modest, supporting amounts.
So don't choose on ceramide count. Both give you a sensible barrier-lipid mix. Choose on niacinamide and on how rich you want the lotion to feel.
Niacinamide is the real difference
CeraVe PM lists niacinamide fourth, right after water, glycerin and caprylic/capric triglyceride. That's a meaningful amount. Niacinamide (vitamin B3) helps reduce water loss, calms redness, and over a few weeks can help with oiliness, the look of pores and uneven tone.
That makes CeraVe PM a two-in-one for oily, combination or acne-prone skin: moisturizer plus a niacinamide step. If you already use a niacinamide serum, you don't need it twice, and Vanicream may be the simpler fit.
Most people tolerate niacinamide well, but a minority get warmth, flushing or stinging, especially on rosacea-prone skin. If niacinamide has bothered you before, choose Vanicream. It contains none.
Apply it to one cheek or your jawline once a day for several days. Mild warmth that fades in minutes is common at first; stop if redness, burning or itching lasts. If you react to most moisturizers you try, see a dermatologist.
Same humectants, different emollients
Both use glycerin and hyaluronic acid to pull water into the skin. What surrounds them is different.
Vanicream puts squalane second on its list, right after water. Squalane is a light, skin-friendly emollient that softens and helps hold water in without feeling greasy. That gives Vanicream a slightly richer feel, which normal-to-dry skin will appreciate.
CeraVe PM pairs them with caprylic/capric triglyceride, cetearyl alcohol and a little dimethicone. It's an oil-free lotion and the lighter of the two. The dimethicone adds slip and a thin protective film.
If your skin is very dry, neither is rich enough on its own in winter. Add a thicker cream on top at night or step up to a richer formula.
How each one wears
Vanicream's squalane gives a soft, slightly dewy finish that suits normal to dry skin. CeraVe PM sinks in faster and feels lighter, with a smooth, silky touch from the dimethicone. On oily skin, CeraVe PM is less likely to look shiny by midday.
Pilling usually comes from too much product or layering too fast, not from one bad moisturizer. To avoid it:
- Use a pea-to-nickel-sized amount on slightly damp skin.
- Wait a minute or two before sunscreen.
- Pat sunscreen and makeup on instead of rubbing back and forth.
- If pilling continues, use less moisturizer before you change products.
Neither contains sunscreen, so in the morning follow either one with a broad-spectrum SPF 30 or higher. CeraVe PM's light silicone slip makes it the slightly easier base under makeup.
Irritation and breakouts
Both are free of added fragrance, which removes the most common cause of moisturizer reactions. Fragrance-free still doesn't mean nothing can bother you, as our piece on what fragrance-free labeling actually indicates explains.
Vanicream has the shorter, plainer list: 19 ingredients, with no niacinamide, silicones, botanicals or essential oils. CeraVe PM has 24 and adds niacinamide and dimethicone. If your skin reacts to almost everything, start with Vanicream.
Neither formula contains classic heavy occluders like petrolatum, mineral oil or shea butter. Dimethicone, squalane and fatty alcohols don't clog pores for most people, so judge by how your skin actually responds over two or three weeks.
For breakout-prone skin, CeraVe PM is the better bet. It's lighter, non-comedogenic, and its niacinamide helps with oil and redness. Vanicream is also non-comedogenic, but its squalane-rich base suits normal to dry skin better than oily skin.
Questions before you choose
Can a fragrance-free moisturizer still cause irritation?
Yes. Fragrance is only one trigger. In these two, the ingredient most likely to bother reactive skin is CeraVe’s niacinamide, which occasionally causes flushing or stinging.
Is Vanicream the better choice for sensitive skin?
For most sensitive skin, yes. It has no niacinamide, silicones, fragrance, botanicals or essential oils. No moisturizer suits everyone, but Vanicream gives you the fewest likely triggers.
Does CeraVe PM clog pores because of dimethicone?
No. Dimethicone is a small part of the formula and isn’t known to clog pores. CeraVe PM is non-comedogenic, and it’s the better pick of the two for acne-prone skin.
Can I use CeraVe PM in the morning?
Yes. “PM” is just the name. Nothing in it reacts to sunlight, so it works under sunscreen in the morning too.
Apply a small amount along your jawline once a day for four or five days. If you see no redness, itching or bumps, move to your whole face. Introduce one new product at a time so you know what caused any reaction.
Packaging and value
CeraVe PM comes in a pump bottle, which keeps fingers out of the lotion and doses evenly. A new pump can take a lot of presses before the first lotion comes out. Vanicream comes in a squeeze tube that's easy to travel with and to cut open for the last bit.
Both hold 3 fl oz, and the two usually cost about the same per bottle, so neither has a real value edge. Pick on formula, not price.
When the two-pack makes sense
The Vanicream two-pack is two of the same 3 fl oz tubes. It's worth buying only if it costs less per tube than two singles, and only once you know the formula suits you.
When a tube or pump arrives, check that the seal is intact and that the lotion looks, smells and feels the way it did last time. Anything off is a reason to return it, not to use it.
- Choose Vanicream if your skin is sensitive, reacts to niacinamide, or runs normal to dry.
- Choose CeraVe PM if your skin is oily, combination or acne-prone, or you want niacinamide for oil and uneven tone.
- Buy the Vanicream two-pack only after one tube has worked for you, and only if it costs less per tube than two singles.
Vanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer vs CeraVe PM is mostly a question of niacinamide. CeraVe PM puts niacinamide fourth on its list, alongside three ceramides, cholesterol and a little dimethicone, in a light, oil-free pump lotion. That makes it the better pick for oily, combination and acne-prone skin.
Vanicream skips niacinamide and silicones and leans on squalane, glycerin, hyaluronic acid and five ceramides, with no fragrance, botanicals or essential oils. It’s the safer choice for reactive skin and feels a little more nourishing on normal-to-dry skin. Both work morning or night, under sunscreen.
