A good cleansing oil usually rinses cleaner than a balm. A balm is easier to control.
In the cleansing balm vs. cleansing oil choice, the oil usually wins on rinse. A balm needs a wax, usually polyethylene, to stay solid in the jar, and that wax takes more water and massage to wash off. An oil skips the wax, and both oils here list their emulsifier second or third, so they turn milky almost instantly.
The balm’s advantage is handling. It stays where you put it, doesn’t run into your eyes, and won’t leak in a travel bag. A well-made balm still rinses clean if you add water gradually until it turns milky.
Of the four here, Anua rinses cleanest for the least money. e.l.f. is the value balm. Farmacy and Dermalogica work well but cost more for scent, not better cleansing. All four contain fragrance or essential oils.
Two balms and two oils
An oil has no wax to melt and no wax to rinse. Its emulsifier can also sit higher in the list: Anua’s is second, Dermalogica’s second or third. That’s why oils turn milky faster and leave less behind. A balm can rinse just as clean, but it needs more water and a little more massage.
What a clean rinse looks like
- Makeup and sunscreen are gone
Press a damp white cloth on your hairline, nose and lash line. It should come away clean.
Clean rinseNo color or white cast on the cloth.Not clean yetTint, mascara smudges or sunscreen streaks. - No oily layer
Your skin can feel soft, but water should run off evenly and your towel should stay clean.
Clean rinseSoft skin, no slip, clean towel.Not clean yetA waxy coating, water beading up, or oil on the towel.
Why some cleansers rinse cleaner
Oils and esters dissolve oil-based grime: sebum, sunscreen filters and most makeup pigments. Balms work the same way. The difference is a wax, usually polyethylene, that keeps the balm solid until your skin warms it.
Then the emulsifier takes over. When you add water, it breaks the oil and everything it picked up into tiny droplets that rinse away. A cleanser with plenty of emulsifier high in the list turns milky fast. One with lots of wax and little emulsifier leaves a film.
Your water and your technique matter too. Hard water, too much product and rushing the milky stage all leave more behind, whichever format you use.
What we compared
We judged each cleanser on the three things that decide how cleanly it rinses: where the emulsifier sits in the ingredient list, how much wax holds it solid, and what else is added.
-
Emulsifier position
The higher the emulsifier in the list, the faster the cleanser turns milky and the less it leaves behind. Both oils list theirs second or third. Both balms list theirs in the top four.
-
Wax content
Balms need polyethylene or a similar wax to stay solid. That wax is the hardest part to rinse, which is why balms need more water and massage than oils.
-
Extras and scent
Botanicals, peptides and ceramides have little time to work in a rinse-off. Fragrance and essential oils matter more, because they’re the most likely cause of stinging.
Value is judged per ounce, not per bottle.
Farmacy and Dermalogica use citrus and floral essential oils. e.l.f. and Anua contain added fragrance. If scent makes your skin or eyes sting, none of these is the right pick. Choose a fragrance-free balm like Clinique Take The Day Off instead.
Farmacy Green Clean: a well-made balm with a scent
Clean-rinsing balm with citrus essential oils
Green Clean’s base is cetyl ethylhexanoate and caprylic/capric triglyceride, two light esters that dissolve makeup and sunscreen. PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate comes third, followed by PEG-10 isostearate, so it emulsifies well once you add water. Polyethylene wax keeps it solid in the jar.
Papaya, moringa, turmeric and echinacea get top billing on the jar but do little in a product you rinse off. The scent comes from lime, bergamot, orange peel, ylang-ylang and ginger oils. The jar holds 100 ml.
- PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate and PEG-10 isostearate in the top five
- Melts long-wear makeup and sunscreen
- Stays put around the eyes
- Larger jar than e.l.f.
- Lime, bergamot, orange, ylang-ylang and ginger oils
- Costs more per ounce than e.l.f.
- Papaya and moringa do little in a rinse-off
Green Clean melts long-wear makeup and sunscreen and rinses clean once you work in enough water. It’s the most pleasant balm of the four to use. But e.l.f. uses the same emulsifier for roughly half the cost per ounce, and Farmacy’s citrus and ylang-ylang oils make it a poor pick for reactive skin.
Dermalogica Precleanse: clean rinse, heavy scent
Clean-rinsing oil with a strong essential-oil scent
Precleanse is caprylic/capric triglyceride and apricot kernel oil, with PEG-40 sorbitan peroleate as the emulsifier near the top. That combination spreads fast and turns milky quickly, so it rinses about as clean as an oil gets.
Sunflower, borage and rice bran oils fill out the base. Then come orange, grapefruit, mandarin and lavender oils, plus citral, limonene and linalool. Those give it a strong citrus-herbal scent and add nothing to cleansing. It comes in a pump bottle.
- PEG-40 sorbitan peroleate high in the list for a clean rinse
- Light, fast-spreading texture
- Pump bottle
- Orange, grapefruit, mandarin and lavender oils plus citral, limonene and linalool
- Costs far more per ounce than Anua
- Can run into eyes
It rinses clean and the pump is easy to use. But Anua does the same job with a similar emulsifier and costs far less per ounce. Pick Precleanse only if you love its citrus-lavender scent. Skip it if your skin reacts to essential oils.
Anua Heartleaf: the cleanest rinse for the least money
Fast-rinsing ester oil in a large pump bottle
Anua’s oil is mostly light esters, not heavy plant oil. Ethylhexyl palmitate comes first, and the emulsifier sorbeth-30 tetraoleate comes second, with sorbitan sesquioleate third. With that much emulsifier this high up, it turns milky the moment water touches it and rinses fast.
Sunflower, macadamia, olive, jojoba and grape seed oils add slip. Heartleaf (houttuynia) extract sits near the end of the list. The formula contains fragrance. The 6.76 fl oz pump bottle is the largest here.
- Sorbeth-30 tetraoleate second on the list for a fast, clean rinse
- Light ester base instead of heavy plant oils
- Largest bottle and lowest cost per ounce here
- Pump bottle, no scooping
- Contains fragrance
- Oil can run into eyes
- Won’t change pore size, whatever the name says
Yes, for most people who want an oil. Its emulsifier sits second on the list, so it rinses clean quickly, and the 6.76 oz bottle makes it the cheapest per ounce of the four. It does contain fragrance. If your eyes sting with it, use a separate eye-makeup remover.
e.l.f. Holy Hydration: Farmacy's formula idea for less
Budget balm with the same emulsifier as Farmacy
Holy Hydration is built almost the same way as Farmacy Green Clean. Cetyl ethylhexanoate and caprylic/capric triglyceride dissolve makeup, polyethylene keeps it solid, and PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate plus PEG-10 isostearate make it rinse. It melts on contact and turns milky with a little water.
It adds three ceramides, cholesterol, hydrolyzed hyaluronic acid and peptides. In a rinse-off product they mostly help your skin feel less stripped. It does contain fragrance, along with geraniol and linalool. The jar holds 2 oz.
- Two emulsifiers (PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate, PEG-10 isostearate) high in the list
- Same core design as Farmacy for roughly half the cost per ounce
- Three ceramides, cholesterol and hyaluronic acid soften the after-feel
- Contains fragrance, plus geraniol and linalool
- Small 2 oz jar runs out fast with daily use
- Peptides do little in a product you rinse off
Yes, if you want a balm. It uses the same emulsifier as Farmacy and rinses just as cleanly, at roughly half the cost per ounce. It contains fragrance, so skip it if scent irritates your skin or eyes.
| VS | ||
|---|---|---|
Cetyl ethylhexanoate, caprylic/capric triglyceride, polyethylene wax | Base |
Caprylic/capric triglyceride, apricot kernel oil |
PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate (3rd) | Emulsifier |
PEG-40 sorbitan peroleate (2nd to 3rd) |
Lime, bergamot, orange, ylang-ylang, ginger oils | Scent |
Orange, grapefruit, mandarin, lavender oils |
Jar; stays put near eyes | Handling |
Pump; spreads fast, can run |
Clean with enough water | Rinse |
Fast and clean |
| View | View |
- Light sunscreen Skip both premium picks. Anua or e.l.f. removes everyday sunscreen just as well for far less.
- Heavy makeup A balm is easier to control around your eyes. An oil covers your face faster but can run. Either removes long-wear makeup.
- Sensitive skin All four contain fragrance or essential oils. If your skin reacts to scent, choose a fragrance-free cleanser instead.
- Double cleansing A second cleanse is for heavy makeup days. If you need one every night to feel clean, the first cleanser isn’t rinsing well.
The emulsifier and how much water you work in matter more than whether the cleanser starts solid or liquid.
- Start dry
Dry hands, dry face. Water this early stops the oil from reaching sunscreen and makeup.
- Use a measured amount
Two or three pumps of oil, or a fingertip scoop of balm. More than that is the most common cause of a greasy film.
- Massage for 30 to 60 seconds
Work it over your face and lashes gently until makeup and sunscreen loosen.
- Emulsify in small steps
Wet your fingertips and massage until it turns milky. Repeat two or three times. Skipping this step is what leaves residue.
- Rinse with lukewarm water
Rinse well. After heavy makeup or water-resistant sunscreen, follow with a gentle water-based cleanser.
For more balms, including fragrance-free picks, see the cleansing balm roundup. If you wear light sunscreen and no makeup, does a gentle cleanser remove sunscreen? covers whether you need a first cleanse at all.
Cleansing balm vs. cleansing oil: the oil usually rinses cleaner. Oils skip the wax that makes a balm solid, and both oils here list their emulsifier second or third, so they turn milky fast and leave less behind. Anua is the value pick, with the biggest bottle and the lowest cost per ounce. Dermalogica Precleanse does the same job with a pricier, more heavily scented formula.
Choose a balm if you want control. It stays where you put it, won’t run into your eyes and won’t leak in a bag. e.l.f. Holy Hydration does what Farmacy Green Clean does for roughly half the cost per ounce. None of the four is fragrance-free, so if scent bothers your skin, look elsewhere.
